A Pizza & More

A Pizza & More is known for its authentic, thin crust NY style pizza, made exactly the way it was in the old neighborhood in NYC. We use only the freshest ingredients! Our dough is made fresh three times daily and we use imported tomatoes and the finest mozzarella cheese available. We have a variety of toppings to suit everyone’s tastes from cheese to bbq chicken.

A Pizza & More has been an industry leader in Cortland, introducing locals to new items over the years. Our calzones are made fresh and overstuffed with ricotta, mozzarella and anything else you may care to include. Our cheese steaks come in many different combinations, or you can build one perfect for your tastes. Our stromboli are a hit at every party and are sold by the tray or individually. Our breakfast items are truly unique and have made A Pizza & More the only full service pizzeria in the area.

A Pizza & More understands the need to have choices in payment as well. We accept cash, all major credit cards, personal checks and the SUNY Cortland Connections Account for your convenience. With so many menu items to choose from we are sure to have something for everyone. In addition, “We’re Famous Because We’re Good!” Allow the A Pizza & More family to help with your next party we do catering, too!


104 Main Street, Cortland, NY 13045

Open Wednesday to Saturday 9am – 3am, Sunday to Tuesday 9am – 11:30pm

607 753 7527


12 South West Street, Homer, NY 13077

Open Monday to Thursday 10:30am – 9pm, Friday & Saturday 10:30am – 10pm, Sunday 12 – 8pm.

607 749 5300

A Round Pizza

We are a locally owned and operated pizzeria with fresh ingredients specializing in pizza, wings, calzones and a variety of salads.


4943 NY Rt. 281, Cortland, NY 13045

Open Monday to Friday 11am – 10pm, Saturday & Sunday 11am – 11pm

607 299 4727



120 Main Street, Cortland, NY 13045

Open Monday to Saturday 10:30am – 4am, Sunday 12pm- 4am

607 662 4226

Little Italy

Since 1984, Little Italy Pizzeria has been welcoming customers into our restaurant like family. Our delicious menu options have been inspired by the love of good food and fresh ingredients. Enjoy New York style pizza by the slice or a sub made just the way you like it. You can even select one of our amazing Italian Dinner Entrees with the tastes and aromas from the old country. Don’t feel like leaving your house? We deliver throughout the Homer & Cortland areas. SUNY Cortland Students can use their connection cards and have food brought right to your dorm!


125 South Main Street, Homer, NY 13077

Open Monday to Thursday 11am9pm, Friday & Saturday 11am10pm, Sunday 12 – 9pm

607 749 2344

The Pizza Shop

Pizza, subs, and wings with speciality calzones.


6 Main Street, McGraw, NY 13101

607 836 4600


In 1947 in the western community of Batavia, New York most people had no idea of what a pizza was. The Italian-Americans in the area, just like the many other ones in the U.S., brought their recipes and food culture to our nation. The popularity of this tomato pie, which had its origins in Naples, Italy grew rapidly. In a time before pizza chain restaurants popped up in every town, it was the Italian neighborhoods that brought pizza to the greater populace. Tony Pontillo, the co-founder of the original Pontillos, quipped, “The popularity of pizza took off and the rest is history!”

Ronald Constantino worked for his uncle Sam Pontillo, another co-founder, at the original Pontillos in Batavia since 1974. In 1982 Ronald and Lynda decided to move their family of three: Jeffery; Brian; and Kristine to Cortland. They opened a small pizza shop, Pontillos, on South Main Street. Ponitillos moved from South Main Street in 1984 to its present location on Groton Avenue.

Jeffery, Brian and Kristine worked along with their parents in the restaurant since they were young. While other children might be doing the dishes at home as a family chore, the Constantino children might be helping to clear the tables in the restaurant. Perhaps this is what created the family-friendly atmosphere that people in Cortland have come to know and love.

Jeffery (the oldest son) took over the restaurant in 2006, along with his wife Pimjai Constantino. They have enjoyed carrying on the philosophy of providing great food in a homey atmosphere, just as Ronald & Lynda did. Keeping the tradition of using the original hand tossed pizza recipe, and making homemade dough. You can always get award winning chicken wings, a Cortland favorite, as well as their many other delicious Italian dishes.

For 35 years the Constantino family is proud and honored to be a part of Cortland and they look forward to serving you for many more years.

124 Groton Ave, Cortland, NY 13045

Open Sunday to Thursday 11am – 11pm, Friday & Saturday 11am – 1am

607 753 3655

Pudgies Pizza & Subs

75 North Main Street, Cortland, NY 13045

Open Sunday to Thursday 11am – 11pm, Friday & Saturday 11am – 1am

607 756 0900

Spiedini’s Pizza Parlor

Here at Spiedinis we are bringing quality food at a low price like no other in town. Also new to the area will be marinated chicken speedie subs.

105 Main Street, Cortland, NY 13045

Open Monday 4 – 11pm, Tuesday 11am – 11pm, Wednesday 11am – 11:45pm, Thursday to Saturday 11am – 3pm, Sunday 11am – 10pm

607 543 4207